A note on the sunspot and prominence records made by Angelo Secchi during the period 1871–1875

– Angelo Secchi (1818 – 1878) was an Italian Jesuit who made relevant scienti ﬁ c contributions in geophysics, meteorology, and astrophysics. He was a well-known pioneer in solar physics due to his theories and observations. Secchi published Le Soleil (The Sun) a summary of knowledge about our star in that time. Moreover, he published in this book his sunspot and prominence observations made during the period 1871 – 1875. In this work, we present a machine-readable version of these observations and a preliminary analysis of them.


Introduction
Pietro Angelo Secchi (1818Secchi ( -1878 was an Italian Jesuit who made relevant scientific contributions (Moigno, 1879;Chinnici, 2019;Chinnici & Consolmagno, 2021). He entered the Jesuit order at Rome in 1833. He studied in the Collegio Romano and later was a professor of Physics and Mathematics. Between 1848 and 1850, Secchi lived in England and worked at Stonyhurst College with Father Weld, the first director of the observatory of that institution. Later, he moved to the United States, where he got his doctorate in theology and taught natural sciences at Georgetown University. He returned to Rome in 1850 and became the director of the Osservatorio del Collegio Romano.
Secchi carried out studies in different scientific areas, for example, meteorology and astronomy (Chinnici & Consolmagno, 2021;Udías, 2021). Secchi was interested, for instance, in climate and the relationship between magnetic observations and weather. Moreover, he constructed the meteorograph, an instrument to record automatically atmospheric pressure, temperature, wind, and rain in short intervals (Anonymous, 1879). As an astronomer, Secchi was the first to make systematic spectroscopic observations in stellar classification. Thus, one of his main astronomical works was the spectral classification of stars in four different types. Besides, Secchi was the first who suggested that the solar core is gaseous, and its temperature decreases from the center to the surface. He was a pioneer in applying the heliospectrograph. He also did significant works in solar observations (including eclipses), comets (discovering the comet currently known as C/1853 E1 Secchi), planets, inter alia. In particular, he was an outstanding astronomer in studying sunspots and prominences, observing them both visually and spectroscopically. Secchi provided the first demonstration that prominences are solar phenomena. Some of his theories on sunspots, granulation, and prominences are outdated, but he had a great relevance on astronomy and solar physics of that time.
Many societies around the world recognized the excellent work made by Secchi, such as the Royal Astronomical Society and the French Academy, he was even the president of the Academia dei Nuovi Lincei. Undoubtedly, Secchi is one of the most relevant solar physicists of history. He kept a detailed archive of drawings of the Sun since 1858 in his notebooks. The drawings depict sunspots, distinguishing between umbra and penumbra, along with facular regions near the limb and prominences. Analysis of the archival documents reveals that in the 1870s, Secchi's collaborators made observations, among others Giuseppe Lais, Gaspare Ferrari and Francesco Marchetti.
There are several published tables of measurements of solar features by Secchi in archival documents (Secchi, 1855(Secchi, , 1864(Secchi, , 1871a(Secchi, , 1871b(Secchi, , 1872. One such summary of his knowledge and observations of the Sun was his book titled "The Sun". It was first published in 1870 in French as Le Soleil, followed by German, Spanish, and Italian translations in 1872, 1879, and 1884. However, it was not until the second French edition (published in 1875) that tables summarizing information on solar features were included. The focus of this work is to present Secchi's solar observations published in Le Soleil (Secchi, 1875).
The outline of this work is as follows. Once contextualized the work of Secchi, highlighting his scientific figure, we present the sunspot and prominence observations published by Secchi (1875) in Section 2. A primary analysis of these observations is shown in Section 3. A summary and the main conclusion of this work are exposed in Section 4.

Solar Activity Records by Secchi in Le Soleil
A summary of Secchi's sunspot and prominence observations for 1871-1875 was published in the second French edition of Le Soleil (Secchi, 1875). The first volume of this edition is divided into four parts. The first one is about the structure of the Sun, the second one on its surface, the third one on the solar atmosphere, and the last one on the eclipses. The second volume is also divided into four parts. In this case, each part deals with (1) sunspots, solar prominences and eruptions, (2) temperature of the Sun, (3) solar activity, and (4) stars.
Secchi included his sunspot and prominence records in the first part of the second volume of Le Soleil. These observations are presented in seven tables. The information included in the tables are: - Each row in the tables shows the statistics calculated by Secchi of the variables previously indicated for each solar rotation. Each table includes 62 solar rotations (62 rows), named by Roman numerals from I to LXII and defined with dates different from the known Carrington rotation. The first one starts on 23 April 1871 and the last one on 11 December 1875. Figure 1 shows an example page of these tables. Note that each solar rotation does not include the same number of days.
Secchi explained that there are two methods to observe prominences. One is to record them in an image composed by lines divided by 360 parts (representing the degrees of a circumference). The advantage here is that observations in different days can be put together in the same sheet, which allows us to see the daily evolution of the prominences. However, Secchi (1875, p. 129) points out that the relationships between , sunspots (black regions on the solar disc), and faculae (white regions on the solar disc) were recorded. Inclined black lines indicate the solar axes ("Est" means East, "Ouest" is West, "Pole N." and "Pole S." indicate the solar north and south, respectively). The horizontal black lines are upper linea reference indicated by Secchi to obtain the position of the celestial equator, and lower lineits parallel diameter given by "a-b" line representing the celestial equator [source: Secchi, 1875, p. 131]. Table 1. Some example lines of the machine-readable version presented in this work on the sunspot and prominence observations made by Secchi published in Le Soleil. The first column shows the number of each solar rotation in Roman numerals, followed by the date (year-monthday format) when the solar rotation starts, the number of prominences in the northern and southern hemisphere respectively, the number of observation days of prominences, the daily average of the prominence number, the number of new sunspot groups observed for each solar rotation, the sunspot area (one unit is defined such as 1 mm in height corresponds to 8 arcseconds and one degree at the limb corresponds to 16 arcseconds), the number of observation days in the case of sunspots, and the daily average of sunspot area. prominences and other solar phenomena such as sunspots cannot be seen by that method. For that reason, Secchi decided to use another method. He recorded all solar phenomena in the same observation sheet by representing them in a disc with a disc projection of 244 mm diameter. Secchi (1875, p. 130) also noted that 1 mm in height in his drawings corresponds to 8 arcseconds and one degree in the drawing at the limb corresponds to 16 arcseconds. Figure 2 shows the reproduction of the drawing made by Secchi around the maximum of Solar Cycle 11, on 23 July 1871 between 8:30 and 9:55 am. We have made a machine-readable version of the data included in the seven tables previously mentioned. Our digitized version can be downloaded on the Historical Archive of Sunspot observations (http://haso.unex.es). Table 1 depicts some example lines of the machine-readable version presented in this work.

A primary analysis of the observations
We have consulted the second French edition of Le Soleil as well as the Spanish translation. On the one hand, we also detected errors in the values published in both editions, such as, for example, in Table A for rotation VI where the daily average of sunspot areas is 56.7 (see Fig. 1), but if we divide the total area for that rotation by the number of observation days, it is 46.7. Then, this error seems due to an erratum as well as others like that. On the other hand, we found some differences in the values included in the tables of both editions. For example, in Table B for rotation II, the total number of prominences observed in the northern hemisphere was 188 according to the second French edition of Le Soleil (Fig. 3), and it is 198 according to the Spanish translation. In this case, if we sum the total number of prominences recorded in different heliographic coordinates, the result is 188. Therefore, that also seems erratum in the Spanish edition. Note that we also provide a list of suspicious data in our machine-readable version of the data.
The number of groups in each rotation recorded by Secchi in Table A and the number of observation days, is represented in Figure 4 (top panel). It can be seen that how, in general, the number of groups decreases from the first records by Secchi to the last ones. That is because the maximum of that solar cycle (Solar Cycle 11) was around those first observations. The following minimum was in 1878 according to the sunspot number index provided by the Sunspot Index and Long-term Solar Observations (SILSO, https://wwwbis.sidc.be/silso). We have also depicted the groups recorded in the Royal Greenwich  Table B published by Secchi, including information on the distribution of prominences in heliographic latitudes [source: Secchi, 1875, p. 162].
Víctor M. S. Carrasco et al.: J. Space Weather Space Clim. 2021, 11, 51 Observatory (RGO) (Willis et al., 2013;Vaquero et al., 2016) corresponding to the same solar rotation defined by Secchi. In general, the number of groups recorded in RGO was lower than that by Secchi. However, this should be taken with caution because we have not considered the same observation days to calculate those values. Other reasons that can contribute to that difference can be different observation methodologies, the kind of telescope used in both observatories, and even the  Víctor M. S. Carrasco et al.: J. Space Weather Space Clim. 2021, 11, 51 meteorological conditions. One outstanding fact is that Secchi's observations can fill gaps in the RGO series in those first two years of observations at RGO.
We also represented the daily average of the number of prominences recorded by Secchi (Fig. 4, bottom panel). It has the same behavior as that followed by sunspot groups: larger number of prominences around the maximum and values decreasing as the solar cycle progresses until the following minimum. Furthermore, we have represented the butterfly diagram of the total number of prominences recorded by Secchi (1875) in each solar rotation for 1871-1875 (Fig. 5). Dark colors depict the lowest numbers of prominences observed by Secchi whereas light colors mean the largest. The number of prominences is represented in intervals of 10°in latitude as done by Secchi in his notebooks. It can be seen that the largest number of solar prominences (included at high latitudes) appear around the maximum of Solar Cycle 11. The number of prominences observed at high latitudes decreases from the maximum of the cycle to the minimum of the following solar cycle. This agrees with the result obtained by Chatterjee et al. (2020) by studying the latitude distribution of prominences from Solar Cycle 15 to 24 using data from the observatories Kodaikanal, Meudon, and Kanzelhöhe. Moreover, it can be seen that a new pattern in the number of prominences recorded by Secchi started around the end of 1875. Note that the poleward and equatorward migration of prominences was indicated for the first time by Secchi (1872). He analyzed his solar observations made during 1871 and concluded that the number of prominences above 40°and 60°in latitude increased until the fourth solar rotation defined by him (around August 1871) in the case of the Northern hemisphere and the third solar rotation (around July 1871) according to the Southern hemisphere and then decreased. He also pointed out that fact coincided with the decrease of the number of spots he observed around the beginning of September 1871.

Conclusions
Angelo Secchi published in Le Soleil a summary of knowledge about our star in the early 1870s and his prominence and sunspot observations for the period 1871-1875. This book can be considered as one of the most relevant works in the history of solar physics. In fact, although prominences were observed previously, Secchi's prominence observations are the first systematic records of solar prominences available in solar physics. It is worth noting that Secchi studied the solar phenomena in collaboration with Pietro Tacchini, Lorenzo Respighi, and Giuseppe Lorenzoni. Archival documents reveal the scientific partnership existing among the above scientists.
We have digitized those observations published by Secchi, and a machine-readable version can be download on the website of HASO (http://haso.unex.es). A preliminary analysis of values included in the seven tables provided by Secchi was also made. We have identified some problems in the French and Spanish editions, which are indicated in our digitized version. Furthermore, we have compared the groups recorded by Secchi in different rotations with those made in RGO. Although the number of groups recorded by Secchi is generally larger than that in RGO, we must consider that the values were calculated based on different observation days. Therefore, it should be taken with caution. In addition, we can see that both the total number of sunspot groups in each rotation and the daily average of prominences have the same behavior: larger number around the maximum of Solar Cycle 11 and values lower as the solar cycle progresses until the minimum. Moreover, solar prominences were observed by Secchi next to solar poles around the maximum of Solar Cycle 11, whereas their number decreased from the maximum to minimum of the solar cycle. By studying his observations, Secchi could discover the migration of solar prominences toward the solar poles.
Finally, we note that all the original solar observations made by Secchi are currently being studied. More data from the important scientific activity of Angelo Secchi shall be available in the near future.